Try the grape pie. From Scene Magazine:

[B]esides the colorful vibe, there’s also an integrity to the place, thanks to its close association with ArtsCollinwood, a nonprofit that supports local artists and works tirelessly to help stabilize this older, transitional neighborhood. Not only did ArtsCollinwood volunteers help renovate the space, but the café is also physically connected to the ArtsCollinwood Gallery. Factor in the ever-changing collection of local artwork hanging on the café walls and the local musicians who sometimes entertain here, and it’s no wonder the spot gives off a sense of down-home authenticity, like something you’d expect to stumble across in a small college community…

Cleveland - Restaurants - Café Quirky