- John Polk said “I knew Charles when he was EVP of The Atlanta Chamber and I worked for ...” on Memories of Oklahoma City circa 1993
- John Polk said “Back in the mid-80's and early 90's, Cleveland was actually recognized as one of the ...” on Economic development in NEO: A view from the street-level
- John Polk said “Is there any way to substantiate Dimora's claim re: GCP and the PD, other than ...” on Cleveland’s new development dynamic?
- George Nemeth said “Like all glimmers of newness in CLE+ I expect this one to be crushed too” on Cleveland’s new development dynamic?
- Cleveland’s new development dynamic? | Brewed Fresh Daily said “[...] by Ohio voters, as gambling interests convert the Ohio constitution into a zoning ordinance. ...” on Ohio’s casino deal gets a bit more messy
- About BDP Comments
April 3rd, 2012
China, as you’ve often heard, is the world’s fastest growing economy, and not just for its low-cost manufacturing. It’s also home to a rapidly growing consumer market. Big American companies like GM, Harley Davidson and Amway have made big bucks selling to Chinese consumers.
But for smaller American companies, breaking into the Chinese market can be difficult, confusing and expensive.
This week, the Michigan Economic Development Corporation announced a new program to help small businesses make that leap. It’s the first program of its kind in the country.
“The program will offer Michigan companies the opportunity to test their products in the China consumer market with limited risk,” MEDC President and CEO Michael A. Finney said in a release.
As part of the program, the MEDC is partnering with Export Now, a private company that specializes in helping businesses export their products to China. A hundred small Michigan companies will get a chance to take part. For them, the program could be a transformative opportunity.
But it’s also a sweet deal for Export Now, which is based in Ohio. And the owner of a Michigan-based export services company hopes he won’t be left behind.
Export Now, which is based in Akron, started in 2010. Its CEO is Frank Lavin, a former ambassador to Singapore and Undersecretary of Commerce for U.S. Trade.
Export Now typically charges clients $3,000 to send over a pallet of products to China. Export Now handles all the logistics, taxes and customs issues. The products are stored in a warehouse and sold on Tmall.com. The site is basically the Chinese version of Amazon. But way bigger.
“E-commerce in China … is about twice as big as a share of the retail market as it is in the U.S.,” Lavin says. “This platform we’re in in China is the largest e-commerce platform in the world.”
Under the agreement with the MEDC, Export Now will cut $1,000 off the cost of its service for selected Michigan businesses. The MEDC will also pay $1,000. So the total cost to Michigan businesses will be $1,000 – a discount of two-thirds off the usual price.
But perhaps the biggest winner in the deal is Export Now. It’s a startup company that only began shipping products to China within the past few months. With its new deal, the MEDC will help recruit up to 100 new clients for Export Now. Right now, Export Now has just 11 clients. The MEDC will also directly pay Export Now up to $100,000. The new clients will bring in another $100,000.
Frank Lavin negotiated this deal that could increase his company’s size almost tenfold, all in exchange for a 33 percent discount on Export Now’s services.
“It sounds like a pretty good deal he has,” says Tim Parker, who’s trying to launch an export service business of his own.
Parker says perhaps the best part of the deal is that the MEDC has sent out press releases, and plans to hold four informational meetings across Michigan.
“Any publicity like that is good,” Parker says. “It’s directly building your business for you, and you’re leveraging others’ resources, so of course it’s a good thing.”
Parker started his export-to-China business last year. Unlike Lavin, he’s actually a Michigan resident. But he says his company might be a few months behind Export Now in the race to get U.S.-made products to China. There’s even been talk of partnering with Export Now.
“I guess in some ways, you could think of it as a competitor,” Parker says. But he says his business will market Michigan-made products directly to retail stores. Export Now only sells on the web.
But still, Parker hopes when the time comes the Michigan Economic Development Corporation will help his company, TS Parker Products, just like it helped Export Now.
MEDC spokesman Michael Shore says he hasn’t heard of Parker products, but he says the agency is open to arrangements with other companies that can help market Michigan-made products abroad.
“Export Now came to us,” Shore says. “I can’t speak to any other companies that exist out there, but given similar capabilities, and qualifications and pricing, I don’t why we wouldn’t consider them as well.”
February 15th, 2012
In many ways, the headquarters for Eastern Floral in Grand Rapids, Mich. is like a factory. It’s in an old building with brick walls. The floor is smooth, cold concrete. A noisy printer rattles off new orders.
But of course, it smells amazing in here. Designers stand at long wooden tables, primping and pruning flowers. Red tulips. White daisies. Yellow roses. And just about any other flower you can imagine.
Bing Goei, the owner, says this work is more like artistry.
“I think you have to be born with that.” he says. “I was not. I admit it.”
Goei says this with a laugh.
But he was born with something else that turned out to be its own asset. He was born with a foreign birth certificate. His parents were Chinese. He was born in Indonesia, then moved to the Netherlands. From there, they moved to Grand Rapids, like a lot of Dutch people before them. Except, they have a Chinese name.
And like many of those immigrants before him, Goei worked hard. He started in the flower business in high school. Now, Eastern Floral has seven locations, about 60 year-round employees – twice that around Valentine’s Day – and the company has over $5 million in annual revenue.
Goei says being an immigrant, and being an entrepreneur, there’s a connection there.
“Almost every immigrant that comes to this country has come because they see America as that land of opportunity,” he says. “So immediately, their drive is to fulfill that dream.”
The data on this backs Goei up.
The Kauffman Foundation reports that immigrants are twice as likely as people born in America to start a business.
Richard Herman is an immigration attorney in Cleveland. Herman and Cleveland Plain Dealer reporter Robert Smith wrote a book called Immigration, Inc.
Herman could go on all day with stats about how entrepreneurial immigrants to the U.S. are.
“Immigrants are filing patents at a two-to-one ratio [compared to] American-born,” he says. “Immigrants are more likely to have advanced degrees than American-born.”
And there’s more:
- In Silicon Valley, half of the tech companies were founded by immigrants. In Ohio, that rate is about 14 percent. It’s 17 percent in Indiana, 27 percent in Illinois and 33 percent in Michigan.
- Nationwide, 40 percent of today’s Fortune 500 companies were founded by immigrants, or the children of immigrants – like Steve Jobs.
Immigration is controversial in this country right now, because of added social service and enforcement costs, and because many believe unemployed American-born people could fill some of the jobs taken up by immigrants.
But in study after study, the data all points in one direction: Immigrants create more jobs than they take.
In the Midwest at least, policy makers are starting to take notice.
“I’m not into the politics of immigration, says Michael Finney, who heads up the Michigan Economic Development Corporation. “The facts of immigration says it’s good any place in the United States. The politics of it, obviously, says something different. And I think there’s just an awful lot of confusion with regard to the kind of immigration that’s really good for the United States.”
Finney says his office does work to increase opportunities for people born here.
“But we’d be remiss if we decided to ignore or work against the immigrant population,” Finney says. “Particularly those that are educated at our universities, and in many cases, they’re earning advanced degrees. And after completing those advanced degrees, we’re requiring them to leave the United States and go back to their country, and compete against us.”
Retaining and attracting immigrants has become a major focus for Finney, and the man who hired him, Michigan Governor Rick Snyder. They’ve started an initiative called Global Michigan.
More programs like it are popping up in the Midwest. In the next story for our series, we’ll look at some of those efforts.
The hope is, investing in immigrants will pay off, like it has many times before in this country.